Mfis Are Loan Sharks, Non Saviours Of The Poor

LAST WEEK, the 2010 Global Hunger Index placed Republic of Republic of India inwards the pit. Except for Bangladesh, Republic of Republic of India fared much below all the other South Asian countries. The same week, Andhra Pradesh proposed an ordinance to curb the malpractices that direct maintain function synonymous amongst microfinance institutions (MFIs) forcing a large publish of rural poor to direct maintain their ain lives. Coming inwards the wake of disturbing intelligence reports of a seemingly unending series driblet dead trip the lite fantastic toe past times modest borrowers, the AP Ordinance, for the get-go time, tries to regulate the plethora of MFIs as well as is probable to render a debt-swap arrangement. “What started off every bit an maiden for social as well as economical upliftment of rural poor has forthwith morphed into a highly competitive describe of piece of employment organisation amongst the sole aim of making profits,” said Chief Minister K Rosaiah. “People are getting caught inwards debt traps as well as they run across no agency out.”

No wonder, the describe of piece of employment organisation has grown manifold. Republic of Republic of India Microfinance Report 2009 tells us that the portfolio of MFIs has grown past times 97 percent, as well as the publish of beneficiaries has gone upwards past times sixty percent. The unprecedented increment is inwards a agency shifting the game from the hands of the villains of the story, the sahukars or moneylenders, to a sophisticated, media-friendly organised degree of neo-moneylenders. These are non the park banias exactly a highly educated degree who literally rob the poor. And they direct maintain done it remarkably well.

Take the instance of this adult woman from Karimnagar district inwards AP, who escaped a suicide attempt. Harassed for non existence able to repay a Rs. 4,000 loan, she was existence forced to sell her house. Another adult woman lost her husband, as well as spell the trunk awaited cremation, the MFI goons were at her door demanding their pound of flesh. While the RBI remains a mute spectator, the finance ministry building likewise is unwilling to act.

The argue is simple. For the banks, microfinance has come upwards every bit a saviour. It is a highly profitable describe of piece of employment organisation amongst assured as well as timely returns. Without making whatsoever effort, all that banks as well as other donors demand to produce is to render refinance at roughly 12 portion interest. The MFIs produce the rest, including timely repayments. These intermediaries add together or as well as so other 10-12 percent, as well as thus halt upwards charging the borrowers anything higher upwards 20-24 percent, which effectively comes to 36 portion on cumulative terms. With to a greater extent than than 98 portion assured returns, the banks couldn’t direct maintain asked for more. Realising that at that topographic point is coin inwards exploiting the misfortunate poor, soul banks as well as companies similar Monsanto, Citicorp, Infosys, ABN Amro, ICICI, as well as fifty-fifty the UN as well as donors similar Ford Foundation direct maintain joined to earn profits from poverty.

The debt-swap that the AP authorities is trying to select inwards is unlikely to stalk the rot. From what appears inwards the media, it is designed to allow the crooks off the hook. While the recent spurt inwards suicides inwards AP as well as Odisha should direct maintain landed many of the MFI CEOs inwards jail, all that the ordinance is trying to produce is to move on on the burden to nationalised banks past times forcing them to direct maintain over the loans. While they volition come upwards nether an unmanageable fiscal burden, the MFIs volition emerge the truthful beneficiaries. In reality, what was 1 time intended to hold upwards a charitable action has forthwith turned predatory. It has resulted inwards multiple borrowings as well as defaults, thereby adding on to the hunger index.

What is needed is to render the poorest of the poor amongst loans non exceeding an annual involvement of iii percent. Like the Society for the Elimination of Rural Poverty inwards AP, which provides such loans to self-help groups (SHGs), the banks are straight linked to the poor borrowers. The remaining involvement is subsidised past times the state. By eliminating the middlemen, the SHGs direct maintain built a corpus of Rs. 5,000 crore.

From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 7, Issue 43, Dated Oct 30, 2010
http://www.tehelka.com/story_main47.asp?filename=Ne301010Proscons.asp